The Best of Dayton awards are a reader-voted contest where neighbors nominate, then vote for, the local businesses they would send a friend to.
For our family, that ballot has turned into a three-year streak: a win, then two straight years as a finalist. Every time a customer tells us they typed our name into a nomination box, it means a great deal to all of us in Brookville.
We also want you to get the most out of an award like this. So this guide walks the parade route: how the program works, what our record looks like, what a local award can and can’t tell you, and how to pair it with the checks that protect your home.
Best of Dayton is run by the Dayton Daily News and Dayton.com. Readers nominate, the most-nominated names become finalists, readers vote, and the top vote-getters win. Treat the result as a signal of local goodwill, then pair it with the BBB, manufacturer credentials, reviews and written estimates before you hire.

Follow the Parade Route
How the Best of Dayton Program Works
According to the paper’s published contest guidelines, Best of Dayton is run by Dayton.com and the Dayton Daily News. It honors businesses, places and people across the region, and every contest moves through the same four rounds.
Nominate
Readers submit the people and businesses they would recommend. The guidelines say a valid email address is all you need, and a business may nominate itself.
Finalists
When nominations close, organizers pick the finalists. The Dayton Daily News says the number of nominations weighs heavily in who makes the list.
Vote
Readers vote category by category. Under the guidelines, each person gets one vote per day per contest, and automated voting is prohibited.
Winners
Winners are announced and featured in a special section of the paper. The guidelines note that runners-up among the finalists are recognized too.
The organizers also keep an eye on the ballot box. The guidelines say they can remove a nominee, reset a poll or drop a finalist when they spot suspicious voting patterns, such as a flood of votes from a handful of computers. That matters, because it means every finalist got there through real nominations from real readers.
The contest guidelines describe Best of Dayton as not “market research or scientific opinion polling.”
That’s not a knock on it. It’s simply what a reader’s-choice award is: a measure of how many people cared enough to speak up.Three Seasons on the Podium, Thanks to You
Here is our Best of Dayton record in one line: Best of Dayton 2024 Winner · 2025 and 2026 Finalist. Tap a placard on the podium to see each year.
The Year You Put Us on Top
Readers voted Thrush & Son® to the top of the ballot. For a family business that has worked out of Brookville since 1960, seeing our name on that list meant more than any ad we could ever buy.
Back on the Final Ballot
The next spring, you put us back on the final ballot. Making the finalist list again told us the first win came from customers who kept talking about their projects long after the crew packed up.
A Third Straight Year
This year we made the finalist list again, our third straight year of recognition. Every nomination came from a homeowner who took a minute out of a busy day to type our name. Thank you.
With Thanksgiving around the corner, it feels like the right time to say it plainly. Every Best of Dayton nomination started with a homeowner who trusted us with the roof over their family, the siding on their walls or the windows they look through every morning.
We don’t take that lightly. Three generations of our family have built this company one job at a time, and if you want the longer version, read our family roofing company history.

What a Local Award Can and Can’t Tell You
A Best of Dayton ribbon in the window is a real signal, and we’re proud of ours. It’s also one data point. Here’s how to read it like a careful homeowner.
What it can tell you
- People know the name. A business doesn’t reach the final ballot without a lot of neighbors nominating it.
- Customers cared enough to act. Voting takes effort, and people rarely bother for a company that let them down.
- It’s rooted here. Reader’s-choice contests reward businesses people meet in their own neighborhoods.
- A repeat means a pattern. One win can be a good year. Several years on the ballot point to steady work.
What it can’t tell you
- Whether the crew is insured and trained for your specific project.
- What the warranty covers, for how long, and who stands behind it.
- How the company handles a complaint when something goes wrong.
- Whether the price and scope on your estimate are fair. Only competing written estimates show that.
Keep the math in mind, too. Larger companies with longer customer lists can gather more nominations, and a newer shop may do excellent work before its name is widely known. So treat any Best of Dayton result as a strong first filter, not the final word.

Cast Your Ballot Before You Hire
Awards are your neighbors’ votes. Your contract is the one that counts. Mark a candidate on the ballot below and we’ll stamp it and show you exactly how to verify it.
Pick a Candidate
Each line on the ballot is something a local award can’t confirm for you. Mark one to see the quick way to check it yourself before you sign.
Read Wide, Read Recent
Read reviews on more than one site and sort by newest. Look for details about the actual job and for how the company answers complaints. The FTC has a final rule banning fake reviews and testimonials, but careful reading still matters. Then ask for local references and call them.
Get It on Paper
Ask for the warranty document itself, not a brochure. Find out what the manufacturer covers, what the installer covers on workmanship and for how long. The Ohio Attorney General says warranties and guarantees belong in the written contract.
Find the Front Door
Confirm a permanent business address you could drive to, and ask how long the company has worked in your area. Then search the name with the Better Business Bureau and the Ohio Attorney General to see whether complaints are on file.
Check the Source
Ask which manufacturer credentials the company holds, then confirm them on the manufacturer’s own contractor locator instead of a sales sheet. Our guide to the GAF President’s Club explains what one of those programs requires.
Ask About the Last Hour
Ask how the crew protects landscaping, siding and windows, where the dumpster or trailer will sit, and how loose nails are picked up at the end of each day. Then ask a reference about cleanup. It’s the detail neighbors remember.
Pair Best of Dayton With Four Other Checks
- 01
BBB Rating and Complaints
The Ohio Attorney General suggests checking a contractor with the Better Business Bureau and the AG’s office to see whether complaints are on file. Read how each complaint was answered, not just the letter grade.
- 02
Manufacturer Credentials
A Best of Dayton honor shows local trust. A manufacturer credential shows a company met that maker’s standards. Confirm it directly with the manufacturer.
- 03
Recent, Detailed Reviews
Look for patterns across several sites over the last year or two. One glowing review proves little; twenty specific ones describing roofs, siding or windows near you tell a story.
- 04
Three Written Estimates
The AG recommends at least three written estimates from three different contractors and warns against a large down payment before the work is done and inspected. Our guide on how to pick a contractor walks through each step.

Use the ribbon to build your short list. A Best of Dayton finalist is a reasonable place to start calling. Then let the BBB, the credentials, the reviews and the written estimates decide who earns the job.
The Takeaway Worth Sharing
A Best of Dayton ribbon tells you your neighbors trust a name. Your own checks tell you whether that name fits your home. Use both.
Send this to the neighbor who’s collecting estimates this fall.
Thank You, Dayton. Let’s Get Rolling.
Thrush & Son®: family-owned exterior pros since 1960.
If you’re in the Miami Valley and planning a roof, siding, windows or doors, read the Thrush & Son® story behind our Best of Dayton finalist honor, then book an estimate with the family your neighbors voted for.
➡️ Schedule in Dayton➡️ View All ServicesCall (937) 833-5136 · 115 Jefferson St, Brookville, OH 45309
- GAF President’s Club Contractor
- Best of Dayton 2024 Winner · 2025 and 2026 Finalist
- BBB Accredited A+
- Since 1960
Further Reading
Official sources: the Dayton Daily News contest guidelines and nomination and voting page, the Ohio Attorney General, the Federal Trade Commission and the Better Business Bureau.
Best of Dayton FAQ
Who runs the Best of Dayton awards?
The Dayton Daily News and Dayton.com run the contest. Readers nominate, the most-nominated names become finalists, and readers vote to pick the winners.
How are Best of Dayton finalists chosen?
After nominations close, the organizers choose the finalists, and the number of nominations a business receives weighs heavily in who makes the ballot.
How often can I vote in Best of Dayton?
The published guidelines allow one vote per day per contest, and automated voting is not allowed.
Has Thrush & Son® won Best of Dayton?
Yes. Our record is Best of Dayton 2024 Winner · 2025 and 2026 Finalist, thanks to customers and neighbors across the Miami Valley.
Is a local award enough to choose a contractor?
No. Use it as a first filter, then check the BBB, manufacturer credentials, recent reviews, three written estimates and a written contract before you sign.
Written by Corey Thrush, Vice President and third generation of Thrush & Son®.


Leave a Reply