Those Icicles Are a Heat Leak. Here’s How to Close It.

Ice damming on a residential roof with ice and meltwater backing up at the eaves
Ridge Run Trail Map · Winter Edition

Ice Damming, Run by Run

Ice damming happens when a warm roof deck melts the snow up high and that water refreezes at the cold eaves, building a ridge of ice that traps the next round of meltwater.

Ohio winters swing above and below freezing, exactly the weather it needs. And it rarely starts outside. The ice is the symptom. The cause is heat leaking out of the house and into the attic.

So this guide reads like a trail map. The roof is the mountain: green circles are easy DIY, blue squares take a weekend or a pro, and black diamonds belong to a pro. Start at the ridge.

Ice damming on a residential roof with ice and meltwater backing up at the eaves
Trail poster · where the ice meets the eave
Trail map · pick a run

What’s In This Guide

Lodge chalkboardThe 30-second versionRead time · 9 minutes

Ice damming at the eaves means heat in the attic. Seal the air leaks first, then insulate, then ventilate so the whole roof stays cold. Put a leak barrier at the eaves when the roof is replaced, rake snow from the ground, and never chip at the ice.

Run 01 · Green circle · Easy read

What Causes Ice Damming?

The University of Minnesota Extension lays out the recipe plainly: the higher part of the roof surface sits above 32°F while the lower edge stays below it. Snow melts up top, the water runs down, reaches the cold edge and freezes.

Each melt adds a layer until fresh meltwater pools behind the ridge. Shingles shed water running downhill; they aren’t built to hold back a puddle. Extension notes that the trapped water finds cracks and openings and flows into the attic.

Where does the heat come from? Extension is direct: it “primarily comes from the house.” Warm air leaks through ceiling gaps and heat creeps through thin insulation, while the overhang outside the heated walls stays as cold as the air. That temperature split is the whole story of ice damming.

Trail noteExtension flags recessed lights, skylights, complex roof designs and heating ducts in the attic as features that raise the risk.

Ice damming at the eaves of a snowy winter roof with long icicles along the gutter
Long icicles at the gutter are the trail marker. The heat source is uphill.
32°FThe line between melt and refreeze that drives ice damming.
R-38The ceiling insulation level UMass Amherst suggests for northern U.S. homes.
24″How far past the exterior wall line Ohio’s code carries the eave ice barrier.
Run 02 · Blue square · Try it

Turn the Attic Thermostat

Slide through the four settings below. Each one fixes one layer of the attic, and you can watch ice damming fade: the melt zone, the refreeze ridge and the icicles all shrink as the roof deck cools.

Attic thermostat · warm to cold

Setting 1: Warm & leaky

Warm air rises through gaps around light fixtures, pipes and the attic hatch. The upper deck climbs above freezing, the snow melts and the eave builds a thick ridge of ice. This is classic ice damming, and the leak risk is high.

  • Melt Heavy
  • Ridge Tall
  • Icicles Long

Setting 2: Air sealed

The gaps are closed, so warm air stops reaching the attic. ENERGY STAR notes that air sealing, combined with attic insulation, can help alleviate ice dams. Heat still conducts through thin insulation, so a smaller ridge forms.

  • Melt Moderate
  • Ridge Medium
  • Icicles Medium

Setting 3: Insulated

Deep, even insulation slows heat moving up through the ceiling. The deck stays closer to the outdoor temperature, and the icicles shrink.

  • Melt Light
  • Ridge Low
  • Icicles Short

Setting 4: Vented

Cold air enters at the soffits and leaves at the ridge, carrying off stray heat. The roof stays cold, the snow stays put, and ice damming has nothing to work with.

  • Melt Minimal
  • Ridge None
  • Icicles Gone
Tap a setting to watch ice damming change in the roof cross-section.
Run 03 · Blue square · Weekend or pro

Seal, Insulate, Vent: In That Order

The lasting fix for ice damming lives in the attic, not on the shingles, and the order matters. Extension’s first long-term step is to make the ceiling airtight so no warm, moist air can reach the attic. Insulation comes second. Ventilation comes third.

Like chairlift towers, skip one and the cable sags. Air sealing and insulation pay you back all year, too; our guide to energy-efficient home improvements shows where they rank.

Soffit vents and attic ventilation airflow that keeps a roof deck cold in winter
Air in at the soffit, out at the ridge: the cold-roof lift line.
01

Seal the holes

UMass Amherst’s Building and Construction Technology program points out that small holes let significant volumes of warm indoor air into the attic. Target wire and plumbing penetrations, light fixtures and the attic hatch.

02

Add depth

UMass suggests roughly R-38 for northern U.S. ceilings. Michigan’s preparedness guide calls for at least R-30, with R-38 preferable in northern climates. Watch the area above the exterior walls; it’s a common weak spot.

03

Let it breathe

UMass calls soffit-to-ridge ventilation the most effective scheme for cooling roof sheathing, with about a 2-inch air channel kept open above the insulation. Michigan’s guide adds that venting keeps the attic air cold.

Reality check from Extension: once heat loss is under control, only small amounts of roof ventilation are needed, and it doesn’t recommend mechanical attic ventilation for ice damming in Minnesota. Vents still dry the attic and dump summer heat.

Run 04 · Blue square · Roofer’s job

The Eave Leak Barrier: Your Backup Plan

Even a well-sealed attic can see some ice damming in a nasty thaw-and-freeze week. That’s why the lowest edge of the roof gets a self-adhering leak barrier under the shingles.

24″Minimum inside the exterior wall line

Ohio’s residential code, Ohio Adm. Code 4101:8-9-01 (section 905.1.2), requires an ice barrier in areas with a history of ice forming along the eaves and backing up water.

It runs from the lowest roof edge to a point at least 24 inches inside the exterior wall line, and that 24 inches is measured along the slope.

On a deep overhang the barrier must climb farther up the roof, so a careful roofer measures from the wall line, not the gutter. UMass calls these membranes a redundant layer of protection for eaves, valleys and skylights. A leak barrier keeps trapped water out of the house, but it doesn’t stop ice damming; only a cold roof does that.

It’s the first of seven parts in a shingle roof system; see our guide to roofing system components.

  1. Leak barrier
  2. Underlayment
  3. Starter strip
  4. Shingles
  5. Flashing & drip edge
  6. Hip & ridge cap
  7. Attic ventilation
Run 05 · Green circle · Easy DIY

Where Gutters Fit In

Gutters get blamed for ice damming all the time, but they don’t create the heat that starts it. What they control is where water goes. A trough packed with fall leaves holds water right at the coldest part of the roof, and that water freezes into a solid block that gives the ice ridge a head start.

November is the month to deal with it: once the last leaves drop, clear the troughs and flush the downspouts. Our gutter maintenance tips walk through each step.

Clean gutters won’t cure a warm attic. They just make sure the melt has somewhere to go.

Run 06 · Black diamond · Careful

Removing Ice Safely: Ground Rules

When ice damming has already built a ridge, relieve the pressure without hurting the roof or yourself. Extension’s warning applies to everyone: anyone on the roof in winter, or working on it from below, risks injury.

Groomed trail

  • Rake from the ground. A long-handled roof rake lets you stand on the ground and pull snow off, per Michigan’s guide.
  • Go gently. Extension and UMass both note a rake can damage roofing or scrape off granules, so skim; don’t scrape.
  • Open a channel. On a warm day, Extension suggests hosing a channel through the dam with tap water, working up from the lower edge. It’s temporary.

Off-piste: skip these

  • Chipping or hammering the ice. UMass warns that more damage is done to people and roofs this way.
  • Climbing a snowy ladder or roof. Ice at the eaves is the slickest footing on the house.
  • Counting on heat cables as the cure. UMass notes they treat the symptom, can embrittle shingles and add a fire risk.
Run 07 · Black diamond · Call a pro

Old Leak Signs and When to Call

Ice damming leaves tracks even after the snow melts. Walk the house this fall, before the first big storm, and look for these clues:

  • Ceiling stains or peeling paint along exterior walls.
  • Damp, matted or discolored insulation near the eaves in the attic.
  • Dark stains or soft spots on the underside of the roof deck at the eave.
  • Musty smells or mold. Extension warns that the moisture can lead to mold and mildew that cause respiratory problems.
  • Big icicles in the same spots every winter.

Call a pro when you see any of these, when the ice is more than you can safely reach from the ground, or when water is already inside. Extension recommends a weatherization contractor who runs a blower door test on the ceiling, and notes a tighter house still needs enough air for combustion appliances. Don’t fix interior damage until ceilings and walls are dry.

❄All runs pass

The Takeaway Worth Sharing

Icicles are a heat leak with a view. Keep the attic cold, and ice damming has nothing to work with.

Send this to the neighbor whose gutters grow icicles every January.

Base lodge · Get it done locally

Seeing Icicles Already? Let’s Look Up There

Thrush & Son®: family-owned exterior pros since 1960.

If you’re in the Miami Valley and your roof grows ice at the eaves every winter, read the Thrush & Son® guide to ice dam prevention for the local plan, then book an inspection.

➡️ Schedule in Dayton➡️ View All Services

Call (937) 833-5136 · 115 Jefferson St, Brookville, OH 45309

  • GAF President’s Club Contractor
  • Best of Dayton 2024 Winner · 2025 and 2026 Finalist
  • BBB Accredited A+
Trail junction · keep riding

Further Reading

Official sources: the University of Minnesota Extension, ENERGY STAR, UMass Amherst Building and Construction Technology, Michigan’s MI Ready program and Ohio Adm. Code 4101:8-9-01 via Cornell LII.

Stay in touch

Stay Connected with the Thrush & Son® Family

Base lodge questions

Ice Damming FAQ

What causes ice damming?

Heat from the house warms the upper roof deck above 32°F, the snow melts, and the water refreezes at the cold eave. The ice ridge then traps more meltwater, which can leak into the attic.

How do I prevent ice damming for good?

Keep the whole roof cold. Seal attic air leaks first, add insulation to a level such as R-38, and ventilate from soffit to ridge so the deck stays near the outdoor temperature.

Does Ohio code require a leak barrier at the eaves?

Ohio’s residential code requires an ice barrier where ice has historically formed along the eaves. It must extend from the lowest roof edge to at least 24 inches inside the exterior wall line, measured along the slope.

Is it safe to chip ice off my roof?

No. Chipping and hammering damage shingles and put you at risk of a fall. Use a roof rake from the ground, or call a pro to open a channel through the ice.

Do gutters cause ice damming?

Not on their own. The heat that starts the melt comes from the attic. Clogged gutters can hold water at the cold edge and help the ice build faster, so clean them each fall.

Written by Corey Thrush, Vice President and third generation of Thrush & Son®.

3 responses to “Those Icicles Are a Heat Leak. Here’s How to Close It.”

  1. Christopher Froehlich Avatar

    Niice blog

    1. Thank you!

  2. […] Related: Ice Damming Prevention. […]

Leave a Reply